Kevin Corrigan

Father Andrew

Max Casella

Paul

Thomas Jay Ryan

Father James

Natalie Carter

Nurse Sara

Marjorie Johnson

Elisabeth

Eva Dorrepaal

Anna

Annie McCain Engman

Shelly

Edward Carnevale

Jimmy

Vít Hořejš

The Puppeteer

Craig Bierko

The Sinner

Paul Reiser

The Dad

Richard Mark Jordan

Alan Ceppos

Franck Raharinosy